HS335 If I Were You
TECH
Low-tech
CHALLENGE
Simple
TIME
1 session (half-day)
TEAM SIZE
1 or 2
About
Students learn best from each other. If I Were You (III) is a way for you to talk about your design work with your classmates and to get advice from each other.
What you need
- A group of about five designers to work together.
- A place to work quietly, with chairs and tables.
- Papers and pens or pencils.
- About 1–2 hours to do it properly.
How it’s done
- One student is made timekeeper to make sure that the rules and timings are followed.
- Taking it in turns, a student presenter explains their design project and ideas to the group.
- The presenter has 5–10 minutes to explain their design project and ideas to the group.
- The other students (including the timekeeper) are the audience. They listen to the presenter, and ask questions if they have any.
- When the presenter has finished, the audience give their feedback on the presenter’s project, one at a time.
- Each student in the audience has 1–2 minutes to give their opinions and advice.
- They begin their feedback with the words, “If I were you, I would…”
- The student presenter listens and takes notes.
- Once everyone has given their feedback, the presenter summarises the opinions and advice they got to make sure that they understood.
- Then it is the turn of the next student to be the presenter.
Tips
- The timekeeper makes sure that things run smoothly:
- Keep to the timings, or it will take too long and there will be no time left for some of the students to present their work.
- Allow questions from the audience while the presenter is presenting, but it must not become a discussion.
- Make sure that the audience begin their feedback with the words, “If I were you, I would…”
- The presenter only listens and takes notes while the audience is giving feedback.
- Another student takes over the role of timekeeper, when it is their turn to present.
More handouts for students of Level III…
Read the next handout for Level III students (12 to 14 years old).